An ivory-trimmed doorway frames a comfortable family room with an aged brick fireplace, oak floors and autumn light through a wide window.

Bedminster Tavern Reopens: What's New at 285 Main Street

October 22, 2026

In September 2011, the building at Main Street and Hillside Avenue reopened as Delicious Heights Bedminster. You walked straight into a three-walled bar lined with televisions. The dining room moved to leather booths and dimmer lighting, and the second bar, the old Legends Sports Bar with its own entrance, was kept for private parties. On Friday evening, Oct. 9, 2026, after four days closed for renovations, the same building reopened as The Bedminster Tavern. The service area at the bar entrance is gone, and a piano stands in its place. The Legends room is set to reopen to the public as a whisky bar called Stables.

Those are small changes to a 240-year-old building, and they point the tavern back toward the job it held for most of its history as a public room for Bedminster village.

A Building That Has Always Changed Its Name

The tavern's history is easiest to follow through its names, and each new name came with a new idea of what the place was for. In its reopening coverage, The Bernardsville News traced the line of owners:

  1. 1786. Aaron Malick, a wealthy village tanner, built the tavern for his son John. At the time, Bedminster village was called Lesser Crossroads.
  2. 1800 to the late 1800s. William Fulkerson, a Continental Army veteran, bought it, then Peter Blair. Duwick and Agatha Geffkin later called it The Bedminster House.
  3. 1898 to 1963. The Howard family owned it. During Prohibition, William Howard ran a speakeasy there and sold his homemade applejack. In 1937 the building was moved back from Main Street and the Pine Room was added, and it came to be known as the Bedminster Inn.
  4. 1966. Future state Sen. John H. Ewing of Peapack reopened it as The Cock and Bull after extensive renovations.
  5. 1968. Local horse trainer Winthrop Elliot and British-born restaurateur Edward Sharp brought back the Bedminster Inn name.
  6. 1981. John Kissel of Bedminster renamed it The Inn.
  7. 1989. It reopened as Willie's Taverne, named in honor of William Howard, and stayed Willie's until March 2011.
  8. 2011. Delicious Heights Bedminster opened on Sept. 26.
  9. 2026. The Bedminster Tavern.

Through most of those names, the building did civic work. The Bernardsville News lists its past roles as a stagecoach stop, a forum for politicking and electioneering, a polling place, a brewery, a billiard hall and a boarding house. On Oct. 20, 1911, Gov. Woodrow Wilson stopped there to give a campaign speech from the old front porch. He tripped on the steps on the way up, got right back to his feet, and told the farmers waiting at the corner that he was on their side. That speech turned 115 on Tuesday.

The civic thread ran into the modern era. The Township Committee held its annual reorganization meeting in the tavern almost every January from the early 1970s on. That stopped in 2011, when the new layout was not considered a good fit for audience seating.

What Changed on October 9

The newest owner, Alyssa Cranston of Berkeley Heights, already knows the building. She worked at Delicious Heights as a host and server before becoming catering manager at The Bridgewater Manor. She told The Bernardsville News that the goal is something that "fits Bedminster's personality and goes back to its original roots."

The paper reported that the bar and restaurant areas are largely unchanged. The decor is moving toward an equestrian theme, and the servers and bartenders are staying on. Regulars should find familiar faces behind the bar in a room that looks mostly the same, with a piano now near the door.

Cranston is with The Celtic Hospitality Group, a newly formed company based in Bridgewater. Its CEO, Thomas J. McAteer, was general manager of the Ryland Inn in Whitehouse Station. The new chef, Christopher Albrecht, led the Ryland Inn kitchen for the past eight years and cooked at Eno Terra in Kingston before that. McAteer described the goal plainly in the same article: "Our goal is to be the heart of Bedminster."

The township signed off first. The Township Committee voted on Monday, Oct. 5 to transfer the liquor license, and Mayor Larry Jacobs said at the meeting, "Delicious Heights had a nice run. But we welcome Bedminster Tavern, and we look forward to it."

Two Bars Under One Roof Again

The biggest layout change concerns the second bar. In 2011, the general manager explained that the Legends room went private because "two (public) bars in the same building, you're kind of competing against yourself."

The new owners handle that by giving each bar a different purpose. On the tavern's site, the Main Bar is the casual, walk-in-friendly room with televisions, built for meeting a friend or watching a game. The Stables is described as a separate, quieter space for cocktails, wine, an upscale whiskey list and lighter food, "where an evening slows down." Stables seating is by reservation through Resy. The dining room is reservation-led, and the Main Bar takes walk-ins.

For Stables, check before you go. The tavern's site already posts a Stables menu and a reservation link, and Visit Somerset County's listing says it is open Thursday through Saturday. The tavern's own hours page doesn't list separate Stables hours, so calling 908-234-1596 before a Friday night plan is the simplest way to be sure.

What's on the Plate

The kitchen plans "farm to fork" ingredients from local farms, more seasonal dishes and a wider wine list. Albrecht told The Bernardsville News that vegetables carry the identity of each dish: "Every dish has different vegetable components."

You can already see that on the posted menus. The dinner menu includes honey nut squash soup, grilled littleneck clams and beef meatballs, and the pasta section names Valley Shepherd pecorino. The Sunday brunch menu has a Celtic Mixed Green Salad made with Eagle Road Farm carrots. If you'd like a first look before booking, MyCentralJersey published a photo gallery of the new tavern on Oct. 15 showing the food, drinks and live music.

A Week at the Tavern

The posted schedule spreads the tavern across most of the week. Mondays are dark, and Sundays close in the afternoon.

Day Hours What's on
Monday Closed
Tuesday Noon to 11 p.m. Handmade pasta class on Nov. 3
Wednesday Noon to 11 p.m. Trivia night
Thursday Noon to midnight Live music, 7 to 10 p.m.
Friday Noon to midnight Live music, 7 to 10 p.m.
Saturday 11 a.m. to midnight Live music, 7 to 10 p.m.
Sunday 11 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Brunch

The tavern notes that hours can change for holidays and special events.

Pairing a Visit With the Rest of Late Fall

The tavern's Saturday and Sunday hours fit well with two of Bedminster's late-fall outings.

Saturday mornings. The Bedminster Farmers Market runs Saturdays from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. at River Road Park, 3055 River Road, through Dec. 5. That last Saturday is the Holiday Market. On Saturday, Oct. 31, Bedminster Township Recreation is holding a Halloween Trunk or Treat at the market from 10:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. TAPinto Somerset Hills reports that residents who want to decorate a car and hand out treats can contact Neil Mastrobuono at the township, (908) 212-7000, extension 405. The tavern opens at 11 a.m. on Saturdays, so you can go from the market straight to an early lunch.

Sunday, Nov. 1. The Raritan Headwaters Association's Lantern Walk runs from 3 to 7 p.m. at Fairview Farm Wildlife Preserve, 2121 Larger Cross Road. The rain date is Nov. 15. Tickets are $25 for adults and $15 for children, and a lantern comes with each ticket. Sunday brunch at the tavern ends at 4:30 p.m. A late brunch on Main Street followed by an early lantern walk at Fairview Farm fills one afternoon.

Tuesday, Nov. 3. The handmade pasta class is the first special event on the tavern's calendar. Its events page also invites people to join the email list for news on upcoming gatherings and music.

Hearing about a town's landmarks changing hands is part of why I love working in Bedminster and across the Somerset Hills. If you have a favorite memory from Willie's or the old Bedminster Inn, or you're curious what else is changing along Main Street this season, I'd love to hear from you. Holly Lippitt is always happy to talk about the places that make our towns feel like home. Let's Connect.

Let’s Get Started

I am committed to guiding you every step of the way—whether you're buying a home, selling a property, or securing a mortgage. Whatever your needs, I've got you covered.